Essay · 11 November 2026 · 4 min read
The logo is not the risky part of a rebrand
A new logo cannot cost you search traffic. Neither can new colours, a new typeface, or a different line under the name. Search engines do not rank identities. They rank pages, and they find pages at addresses.
So the useful question is not whether a rebrand will hurt your rankings. It is whether the rebrand changes any addresses. Same domain, same URLs, new look: nothing to worry about. New domain, or new product names that turn into new page names: that is a site move, which is a separate project with its own risks, its own timetable and its own line in the budget. Most rebrand quotes do not contain that line.
Will a rebrand hurt our SEO?
Only where it changes URLs, and even then only if the move is done badly. Google's documentation on site moves is plain about the mechanism: permanent redirects "don't cause a loss in PageRank", and keeping them in place is what transfers the signals to the new URLs. The danger is not the move. It is an incomplete redirect map, or a complete one that somebody switches off a year later while tidying up.
That splits a rebrand into two jobs which get managed as one. The identity job is the name, the mark, the colours, the voice. The address job is the domain, the URL structure, and every product name that appears in a path. A studio is hired for the first. Nobody is clearly hired for the second, which is how it ends up with whoever is still awake on launch night.
What a site move actually costs
Not rankings, if it is done properly. It costs time and attention. Google says a medium sized site can take a few weeks or more before the new URLs appear in place of the old ones, because Googlebot has to visit every URL on both the old site and the new one at least once. For the length of that window your reporting will look peculiar, and somebody senior will ask why.
It also costs an inventory. Someone has to list every URL that currently exists, decide where each one goes, and write that map down. Pages that are genuinely gone should return a 404 or 410 rather than being swept into the home page. Redirects should be kept for at least a year, and realistically for good. None of that is design work and none of it is quick, which is precisely why it keeps being discovered late. The same thing happens with the words: a redesign is a content project long before it is a design one.
The bit most teams miss in Search Console
If you are moving domains, Google's Change of Address tool is the formal way to say so, and it expects more than a single request. The guidance is to verify every variant of the old domain, www and non-www, along with any active subdomains, and to submit the change for each of them. The new domain needs verifying too. None of it is hard. It gets skipped because the domain switch is usually the last thing to happen, after hours, by the person holding the DNS login, long after everyone else approved the logo.
Your rankings are attached to addresses, not to your identity.
Renaming a product renames its pages
This is the point where naming stops being a creative decision and becomes a commercial one. Rename a product and the page that ranks for the old name now redirects to a page about a word nobody has searched for yet. Your customers will keep typing the old name for months, and so will the colleagues who heard it from them. The new name has to earn its traffic from a standing start, while the old one quietly stops being typed.
That is not an argument against renaming things. It is an argument for settling the names early, while the cost of each option is still visible, instead of at the end when the only question left is which version of the wordmark survives on a dark background.
Decide the domain before the design starts
The order that works is unglamorous. Settle whether the domain is changing. Settle what the products are called. Then do the identity. The first two decisions set the scope of the build. The third one does not, which is why it should not go first.
And whoever is signing the rebrand off should be told what a domain change costs before they fall for a name that requires one. A rebrand earns its money when the business has actually changed. A domain move earns its money when the name genuinely no longer fits the address. The two arrive in the same meeting, and they are not the same decision.